Alex Song
Theo Walcott
Robin van Persie
Wojciech Szczęsny
Mikel Arteta
Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain
Laurent Koscielny
Thomas Vermaelen
Bacary Sagna
Yossi Benayoun
rvp
kos
sagna
arteta
rosicky
Robin van Persie.
IMO it's not really a debate.
Fulop woz robbed, tbf.
Sagna missed half the season - and then for some reason decided to fuck up regularly in the last couple of matches. But granted, for about 10-12 games since his comeback, he was absolutely phenomenal.
I would go with:
Van Persie
Koscielny
Arteta
As a clear top 3. Rosicky had a good comeback year. Song was mostly good but recently bad. Szczesny did well and then let himself down recently (although, as Wenger says, maybe playing through an injury wasn't the best idea).
RVP
Koscielny
Arteta.
We sell Fabregas and Nasri, end up finishing a place higher, scoring two more goals and having two more points.